The Mêlée Island Prison was the holding place for captured criminals in Mêlée Town. It was located next to the Mêlée Island Church.
During Guybrush Threepwood's Three Trials, he met the pirate Otis who would become one of his first crew members.
He would later once again find Otis imprisoned there along with Stan S. Stanman after Captain Madison had taken control of the island.